Agenda

Appeals Committee - Wednesday 20th March 2024 1.00 pm

Venue: Room G01e, Church Square House, Scunthorpe

Contact: Matthew Nundy 

Items
No. Item

1.

To appoint a Chairman for the meeting

2.

Declarations of Disclosable Pecuniary Interests and Personal or Personal and Prejudicial Interests, if any.

3.

Any other items which the chair decides are urgent by reason of special circumstances which must be specified

 

The public are likely to be excluded from the meeting for consideration of the following item on the grounds that it involved the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972.

4.

Grievance Appeal

4a

Grievance Appeal Procedure

4b

Grievance Policy

4c

Grievance Appeal

Documents Submitted by the Appellant

5.

01 - Grievance - May 2023

5a

02 - Grievance Outcome Report - 31 August 2023

5b

03 - Appeal Against the Outcome of a Formal Grievance dated 31 May 23 - 12.09.2023 (1)

5c

04 - Full Reinvestigation Letter from HR - 28.09.2023

5d

04a - Emails from the Assistant Director: Organisational Development - 25 to 27 September 2023

5e

05 - Outcome of full reinvestigation letter from HR - 25.01.2024

5f

06 - Table of Outcomes - Appeal

5g

07 - NLC Grievance Policy

5h

08 - Disciplinary Policy - page 19 - list

5i

09 - Project Lead Job Description and Essential Criteria (003) - with Notes

6.

Appendix 1 - Project Health Check and Information - Master

6a

Appendix 2 - A Green Future - Programme

6b

Appendix 3 - Project Plan - Ideas

6c

Appendix 4 - Email - Line Manager asking Appellant to run through spreadsheets with Director and Assistant Director

6d

Appendix 5 - CSAMG Action Notes 20th December 2022

6e

Appendix 6 - Email from CSAMG - Asking Appellant to provide update

6f

Appendix 7 - Exception Form - Carbon Trust - Complete - 1st May

6g

Appendix 8 - Screen Shot - Meeting with Legal & Procurement re Appointing Carbon Trust

6h

Appendix 9 - Email asking Line Manager to send Exception to Procurement

6i

Appendix 10 - Screen Shot - Exemption Document Owner

6j

Appendix 11 - Screen Shot - Briefing Director as Aim Lead

6k

Appendix 12 - Decision Making Report Template - Suggested Amendments - February 2023

6l

Appendix 13 - Business Case Toolkit - July 2019 - Suggested Amendments - February 2023

6m

Appendix 14 - Full Business Case - Suggested Amendments - February 2023

6n

Appendix 15 - Mini Business Case - Suggested Amendments - February 2023

6o

Appendix 16 - Project Mandate - Suggested Amendments - February 2023

6p

Appendix 17 - Action Plans - Aim 4 - Written by the Appellant

6q

Appendix 18 - Action Plan - Aim 6 - Written by the Appellant

6r

Appendix 19 - Email to Line Manager for Cabinet Report - March 2023

6s

Appendix 20 - Agenda - A Green Future Board - 19.05.22

6t

Appendix 21 - Agenda - A Green Future Board - 22.09.22

6u

Appendix 22 - Agenda - A Green Future Board - 23.03.23

6v

Appendix 23 - A Green Future - Overarching Risk Register - September 2022

6w

Appendix 24 - Screen Shot - Update Meetings with Line Manager before Board Meeting etc.

6x

Appendix 25 - Risk Assessment Form 24 - Building- The Royal Hotel - 29.11.21

6y

Appendix 26 - Risk Assessment Form 18 - Display Vehicle at Deyne Avenue Car Park - 13.11.21

6z

Appendix 27 - Carbon Literacy Certificate - Appellant

7.

Appendix 28 - Email to Line Manager - Not getting what we need from Aim Leads

7a

Appendix 29 - Screen Shots of Calendar

7b

Appendix 30 - Email asking how we could work as a team in future

7c

Appendix 31 - Email saying intent for new JDs to be put in place by 31st March

7d

Appendix 32 - Email from Line Manager stating that the Appellant is leading on the work with the Carbon Trust - May 2022

7e

Appendix 33 - Email from Line Manager to Jayne Marris saying any questions can be sent to the Appellant

7f

Appendix 34 - Email to show that the Appellant chair's Aim meetings when needed

7g

Appendix 35 - Email from Line Manager asking the Appellant to liaise directly with the Head of Development on AGF Energy

7h

Appendix 36 - Email from the Line Manager asking the Appellant to look at purchasing and setting up Artifax for the Baths Hall

7i

Appendix 37 - Email from the Project Manager asking for information on Artifax as he wasn't involved in this

7j

Appendix 38 - Email response to the Lead Officer for Culture and Creative Partnerships with all Artifax information

7k

Appendix 39 - Emails between the Appellant and Audit

7l

Appendix 40 - Emails between the Appellant and Audit

7m

Appendix 41 - Screen Shot of Audit meetings

7n

Appendix 42 - minutes of board meeting - project leads

7o

Appendix 43 - email from the Appellant to team - project leads

7p

Appendix 44 - Statement

7q

Appendix 45 - Statement

7r

Appendix 46 - Statement

7s

Appendix 47 - Statement

7t

Appendix 48 - Statement

7u

Appendix 49 - Statement

7v

Appendix 50 - Statement

7w

Appendix 51 - Statement

Documents Submitted by the Local Authority

8.

Investigating Officers Report

9.

Timeline